Enterprise Blockchain Doesn’t Work Because It’s About the Real World
Blockchain has come a long way since its 2008 debut as the ingenious technology underlying Bitcoin. Today companies and governments the world over are exploring new applications in which blockchains track, not the flow of digital currency, but things and events in the real world. But this tether to reality is enterprise blockchain’s Achilles heel.
To see why, let’s go back to where it all began. When Bitcoin first appeared, a common reaction was: why would anyone exchange their hard-earned dollars for that? The answer, it’s become clear, is that bitcoin is valuable, and that is a good reason to own some – or, better put, to hold some. How much bitcoin you and everyone else holds is recorded in the Bitcoin blockchain.
Martin Glazier is a philosopher at the University of Hamburg, where he focuses on metaphysics, science, logic and language.
But this is a funny kind of “record.” Most records memorialize real facts, facts that are independent of the records themselves. Take your birth certificate. It records a real event, your birth, which exists apart from the certificate. This is why it is possible for your birth certificate to be inaccurate. It could simply get the facts wrong about when and where you were born.
Bitcoin is different. The blockchain records everyone’s bitcoin holdings, but those holdings are not independent of the blockchain. Quite the opposite: how much BTC you hold depends entirely on what the blockchain says. (Philosophers call this kind of dependence “metaphysical ground.”)
So calling the blockchain a record of people’s bitcoin holdings is misleading. There are no real facts, existing independently of the blockchain, about how much bitcoin everyone holds. Instead, it’s better to say that the blockchain just dictates how much bitcoin everyone holds. What it says goes.
This means that the blockchain has a remarkable property: it is guaranteed to be an accurate guide to people’s bitcoin holdings. Since the blockchain dictates how much bitcoin you hold, it can’t fail to be right in what it says about that.
I’ve mostly been talking so far about blockchain’s application to cryptocurrency. It’s in those applications that the blockchain is guaranteed to be accurate (bracketing so-called double spends or other rare events). But there are many other applications that lack any such guarantee.
Take a case that’s already come up: birth certificates. Births are real events in the world. We can design a blockchain to record those events, but the events themselves are independent of the blockchain. Unlike your bitcoin holdings, no blockchain can dictate when and where you were born. And that means that it is possible for the blockchain to be inaccurate. Nothing prevents the blockchain from just being wrong about your birth.
Of course, just as it is very hard for anyone to tamper with the transaction statements that make up the Bitcoin blockchain, it will be very hard for anyone to alter your birth records once they have been added to the birth certificate blockchain. But that does nothing to ensure those records were accurate in the first place.
The same goes for many other enterprise applications of blockchain. Consider supply chain management. We can design a blockchain to track diamonds from mines to jewelers, but that does not mean the diamonds are where the blockchain says they are.
Or consider health care. We can record on a blockchain that you have been vaccinated against COVID-19, but that doesn’t mean the shot has really gone into your arm.
So we have two big groups of applications of blockchain technology: the ones in which the blockchain is nearly guaranteed to be accurate, like Bitcoin; and the ones in which it is not, like birth certificates. Call the applications in the first group accurate and those in the second group non-accurate.
I don’t want to say that we should only ever pursue accurate applications of blockchain. Some non-accurate applications can still deliver accuracy, if they’re supplemented by something else. For example, if we have some way to ensure that birth certificates are accurate when they’re added to the blockchain, we can be sure they will remain so – even though the blockchain on its own doesn’t guarantee their accuracy. And maybe there are non-accurate applications where accuracy is unimportant, or where the concept of accuracy just doesn’t apply.
But the distinctive potential of blockchain technology lies in accurate applications – applications where the blockchain contains data, not about some independently existing reality like births, but about a reality that the blockchain itself dictates, like bitcoin holdings. In these cases, the blockchain (almost) can’t be wrong.
For a long time, the only accurate applications were to cryptocurrency. But that is changing: the current non-fungible token (NFT) boom is a prime example. The fact that MetaKovan holds a $69 million NFT of Beeple’s digital artwork “Everydays” is not independent of the blockchain. Quite the contrary: his holding that NFT depends entirely on the blockchain’s saying he does. The blockchain dictates who holds which NFTs.
What other accurate applications are there? We might try to extend the example of NFTs to the ownership of intellectual property like copyrights and trademarks or even real property like land and houses. Of course, a house exists independently of any blockchain – but not necessarily from the fact that you own the house.
A reworking of the foundations of property law seems unlikely anytime soon. But perhaps a more viable accurate application is to voting. A jurisdiction (say, West Virginia) could recognize a blockchain, as opposed to a paper ballot, as the final word on what votes were cast. It could be guaranteed to give an accurate vote count.
The price of accuracy is unreality. The Bitcoin blockchain is accurate only because what it “records” isn’t real: bitcoin holdings are shadows cast by the blockchain itself. Enterprise blockchains reach beyond these shadows into the real world – but in doing so they abandon the surety that is the technology’s distinctive promise.
Recommended News
-
Whale Shark’s NFT Collectors Playbook
Thinking about buying some non-fungibles? Maybe you’re even thinking about investing? Maybe you still can’t wrap your brain around the idea of digital art being sold for $69 million, but you’re open-minded, you’ve done your homework and you think the rewards outweigh the risks. And maybe this is money you can afford to lose, so what the hell? [Obligatory disclaimer: Nothing that follows is financial advice. Investing in NFTs – or anything in crypto – is packed with risk and you can lose everything. Proceed with caution.] But if you’re trying to get your…
-
Cutting-edge technologies drive innovation: KHC public chain emerges at the right moment
KHC: redefining finance Traditional financial institutions are called centralized financial institutions. The essence of its business model is to provide value transfer, improve the credit quota and provide insurance service based on credit. This can make capitals flow freely around the world, gather user information, monopolize living sectors including clothing, foods, housing and traveling, and achieve huge benefits. However, traditional financial ecosystem is faced with many serious problems, including black case work, unfair distribution, low benefit ceiling, high threshold, unbalanced regional development, etc. In contrast, DeFi which is decentralized finance,…
-
Singapore Twin Towers Joint Foundation to Create STO Digital Age
First Growth Funds (ASX:FGF) and Singapore City Investment and Development Foundation jointly funded the establishment of Singapore Twin Towers Joint Fund. Currently, the co-management scale of the fund has reached 2 billion US dollars. The main investment areas are financial asset flow, new infrastructure, digital securities ecological construction. Digital new technology research and development and other cutting-edge digital fields. On Singapore’s joint towers foundation based on digital reform by STO, cutting-edge technology can assign the traditional entity enterprise and global popular areas, investment in developing countries for technology, capital,…
-
Market Wrap: Traders Ratchet Up Derivatives Bets as Bitcoin Mounts Rally
Bitcoin (BTC) trading around $58,800 as of 20:17 UTC (4:17 p.m. ET). Climbing 2.1% over the previous 24 hours. Bitcoin’s 24-hour range: $57,069-$59,380 (CoinDesk 20) Bitcoin has climbed on four of the past five days, and the price is now pushing back toward $60,000 for the first time in a couple weeks. “It wasn’t with the fanfare and fireworks, but instead just a standard grind higher, helped in part by the continued positive adoption news flow,” Matt Blom, head of sales and trading with the digital-asset firm Equos, wrote Tuesday in…
-
No Joke: Chipotle to Give Away $200K in Free Burritos and Bitcoin on April 1
Fast-casual restaurant Chipotle Mexican Grill (NYSE: CMG) said it will be giving away $100,000 in free burritos and $100,000 in bitcoin (BTC, +0.12%) in honor of National Burrito Day on April 1. In an announcement, the restaurant said it has teamed up with former Ripple Labs CTO Stefan Thomas to launch a new interactive game called “Burritos or Bitcoin.” The game has been inspired by Thomas, who famously lost the password to his hard drive that now has $387 million worth of bitcoin stored on it. Players will carry out a mock “chiptocurrency” rescue mission and…
-
How NFTs Became Art, and Everything Became an NFT
“Today, the physical mural doesn’t exist. But it still exists with NFTs, and with value,” Boyart tells me from Paris. “This is very satisfying.” See also: What Are NFTs and How Do They Work? Subscribe to State of Crypto, our weekly newsletter on policy impact. SUBSCRIBE By signing up, you will receive emails about CoinDesk products and you agree to our terms & conditions and privacy policy. Boyart minted a non-fungible token (NFT) version of the mural, dividing it into 100 pieces and selling each one for 0.5 ETH. He would sell more NFTs. Many more….
-
Caruso Properties to Accept Bitcoin for Rent, Allocates 1% of Treasury to Asset
California real estate stalwart Caruso properties will now accept bitcoin (BTC, -2.3%) for rent on all its properties. In a partnership with Gemini Exchange, Caruso will now let tenants of its retail and commercial properties pay their rent in bitcoin. This makes Caruso the largest real estate manager in the United States to accept the digital asset as a form of payment. Additionally, Caruso has allocated roughly 1% of its treasury into bitcoin, according to the LA Times. Caruso’s crypto ambitions may not end at bitcoin, though. A press release shared with CoinDesk signals…
-
CoinFans (bi-fans.com) Shenzhen Digital Mining Summit 2021 successfully concluded
On the afternoon of March 17, Beijing time, CoinFans (bi-fans.com) held the “2021 Digital Mining Summit” entitled “Win-win for the future” in Shenzhen. At the meeting, CoinFans CEO James Cao and many other executives attended the meeting. In addition, more than 50 industry elites, customers and strategic partners, including BTC.COM CEO Zhuang Zhong, Antpool co-founder Tian Xin, Shanghai Wayi co-founder Li Peicai, and Guihua Technology co-founder Xiao Guihua, gathered at the summit. At this 500-person summit, James Cao and other well-known companies delivered live speeches and shared the…
-
While current top GameFi’s users are leaving the game，where will they go next? METAEASE rises as a game changer!
The natural anti-monopoly attributes, ultra-high topicality and liquidity nature of GameFi make it an object of pursuit for the rich. The sector as a whole remained on a downward trend this week, with the overall decline in the sector being severe, the trading volumes are maintaining a downward trend and the number of users is also falling to varying degrees. There is no doubt that the GameFi industry is in a downturn, the unprecedented market environment and the fall of many socialites are undoubtedly a big blow to the market. While the overall…
-
Digital currency mining is an inevitable trend in the next five years, CoinFans Mining analysis, mining is getting easier and easier
In 2021 marks the first year of institutionalized mining, which brings both benefits and challenges. CoinFans Mining’s analysis shows that the institutionalization of digital currency mining is an inevitable trend in the next five years, mining will become easier and easier, and everyone will be able to mine, and the mining industry will become an industry. Few investments offer the upside with venture capital-style upside and the downside with infrastructure-style downside case. Combining energy arbitrage with hoarding bitcoin onto a company’s balance sheet can make this happen. Which is why…
